During this season of Indian Idol, a star was born. He possessed all the attributes necessary to win the crown: talent, determination, a dynamic personality, and songs that came straight from his soul. The judges liked him; the people loved him. However, Hyderabadi powerhouse
N.C. Karunya lost the title of Indian Idol II. As did talented Mumbai heartthrob
Amey Date. Amidst the excitement that ensued during the Indian Idol season, the people had formed a winning bond with quiet
Sandeep Acharya, who hails from a small village in Rajasthan, a vast state in the northwestern region of India.
Sandeep Acharya,
newly crowned Indian Idol II, just released his first album under Sony, titled
Mere Saath Sara Jahan. The music was composed by
Sandeep Chowta and
Deepak Pandit. The lyrics were written by
Sameer and
Manoj Muntashir. Did channeling the talent and creativity of such big names do the trick for Sandeep? Lets take a look.
Mere Saath Sara Jahan (Winning Performance)This song is not as good as
Mohabbatein Lutaunga, which was given to
Indian Idol 1, Abhijeet Sawant. However, its not bad. Sandeep sounds a little raw, which was expected considering his performances during the show. The softness required in a few places is not there and that flaw is very apparent. I will say, though, that he stayed in tune, didnt miss notes, and carried the song pretty well overall. The music sounds different but is missing that extra punch needed to make it extraordinary. The lyrics are simple, but I actually like them, especially the second verse.
Ek zarre ko chand banaya, tera shukriya
Tune hi mujhko gaana sikhaaya, tera shukriya
Jo mere paas hai, tera ehsaas haiHe talks about reaching beyond the stars, but in this particular part, he thanks the people who taught him to sing and turned him into a star. This part stands out for me only because when Karunya sang the song during the finals, he did it with so much emotion. Sandeeps rendition isnt as soulful, but Karunyas version stuck in my head. Other than that verse, the rest of the words sort of fade into oblivion. Overall, this song will probably make the charts, but I doubt it will hit the top spots.
Yeh Kaisa Deewanapan HaiThis is a sweet song. The lyrics are typical of Sameer- he is asking what sort of craziness he is suffering from love. Sandeeps high notes sound lovely, but when he hits the low notes, he gets sloppy. A large portion of this song is on the low side, so it often sounds slightly sloppy. He gets the emotions right in some places, and misses the mark in others. However, it is a valiant effort to bring out the innocence of this song in his voice.
Ishq Ho GayaThis is the first song of the album that made me sit up. About a minute into it, I went back to slouching. The flaw in this song lies partly in Sandeeps voice and partly in the composition. As I said before, Sandeep still sounds really raw in places and has trouble bringing out the softness in his voice. But that can be fixed if the composition holds the listener. Here, it doesnt. A good effort, but not quite good enough.
Mere Saath Sara Jahan (Album Version)I tried to get into the feelings behind this song, but Sandeep just couldnt capture me. It sounded as amateurish as the winning performance version. Here, I have to draw comparison between Sandeep and Abhijeet Sawant, last years winner. Both versions of Abhijeets
Mohabbatein Lutaunga were lovely. The proper feeling just didnt exist in Sandeeps songs. The music wasnt very good either- it didnt quite mesh with the song (except for the flute in between). To sum up this song: Its boring.
Mhare Des MeinThis has to be my favorite song on the album. From the minute Sandeep begins singing it, you know its going to be likable. The music is meant to give the feeling of Rajasthan and the music director succeeds in doing so. I also really like the words.
Mhare des mein mhare gaaon mein
In galiyon mein in raahon mein
Bachpan beeta mhara
Aasman ki chhaon mein
Aao pardesi aao
Aao mhare gaaon mein
Aao pardesi aao
Aao mhare des meinHe is inviting outsiders to see the true essence of where he lives- the streets of his village, the village belles, and a childhood spent under the stars. But what makes this song unique is the language. Its not done it typical Hindi some of the words are Rajasthani, which is refreshing to hear. And as for the singing- hats off to Sandeep for this song. Hes done a wonderful job with it. You can tell hes enjoying singing it, too. The best song on the album, hands down.
Papa Kehte HainNow this song was totally unnecessary in this album. Weve heard it a thousand times. In fact, Sandeep sang the same song on the Indian Idol 2 album,
Woh Pehli Baar. I didnt like in on
Woh Pehli Baar, and I certainly dont like it on two different albums. Also, it seemed out of place in an album full of original compositions. Its not very good. Period. I didnt like the music. And the lyrics? Well, weve all heard them before in the original. And the singing is alright, too. Nothing extraordinary. Blech.
Sagar Jaisi Aankhon WaliThis is another remake of an original song. This one is much better than
Papa Kehte Hain, but I still wasnt impressed. Sandeeps singing is tremendously better in this song, but Im still not convinced that he can do soft songs as soulfully as he should. There is no place for this song in this album. Like its predecessor, its out of place among original compositions. I will say, however, that I enjoyed the music. Its close to the original music and the sounds really good!
DholWhen I first heard this song, I thought I was listening to a really bad remix of Dhoom Machale from the movie Dhoom
(Dhoom, dhoom, come on light my fire
). However, when Sandeep started singing, I had to pause for a minute. Where was this Sandeep during Idol galas? He sounds awesome. His voice is unrecognizable, in a good way. Its a little loud and confusing (you have to listen to it to know what I mean), but Sandeeps singing makes up for all the flaws. Yes folks, you heard me. I just said that
about Sandeep. Not Amey. Not Karunya. Sandeep. I surprised myself, too, with that statement. I sort of like this song, second to
Mhare Des Mein. If it had been done in a non-remix style, it wouldve been much better, though.
So, now comes the final verdict. First, the pros. The album is true to Sandeeps identity as a Rajasthani. The music in most of the pieces is reminiscent of Rajasthan, and that makes it stand out. It is a valiant effort by Sandeep. His singing springs very few surpriseshes consistent throughout. The listener knows only to expect one or two gems from an album full of mediocrity. In this case,
Mhare Des Mein is it. And maybe
Dhol. During the galas, it was much the same way.
Holi Khele Raghuveera stood out, but the rest of Sandeeps performances were forgettable. See? Consistency. Well done on that note, Sandeep.
And since Ive halfway started on the cons, heres the rest. The title song isnt catchy and the remaining songs are simply boring. I also think that the lyricists and music directors put in a half-hearted effort in some of the songs. I may have actually liked Abhijeet Sawants album, but I dont like this one.
__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
http://mail.yahoo.com